View source for NSF Final Report AwardNum0653570

=Participants=
 		Tony Forest	   Principal Investigator	Yes
 		Tamar Didberidze	   Graduate student	Yes
               Warren Parsons        Graduate Student      Yes
 		Julian Salamanca	   Graduate student	No
 		Jordan Keough	   Undergraduate student	No
 		Jeremy Lebaron	   Undergraduate student	Yes

=Activities and Findings=
This section will serve as your report to your program officer of your project's activities and findings. Please describe what you have done and what you have learned, broken down into four categories:


== What have been your major research and education activities (experiments, observations, simulations,presentations, etc.)==

The main research focus of the support from this grant was the construction of the Region 1 tracking system for the Qweak experiment at Jefferson Lab.  The Qweak experiment is scheduled to measure the parity violating, elastic scattering of polarized electrons from protons at Jefferson Lab in  2010.  The measurement will be used to extract the weak mixing angle and thereby test the standard model.    The PI for this award is responsible for the design and construction of the Region 1 detector system.  Other activities also undertaken include the testing of prototype drift chambers for the Hall-B 12 GeV upgrade and an analysis of experimental data which will lead towards the extraction of nucleon polarized structure functions.  The progress of these endeavors is described below. 

=== Qweak Region 1 Tracking System Detector Construction===

The design, construction, and testing of the Region 1 tracking system for the Qweak experiment at Jefferson Lab has been the main research activity supported by this grant.  The Qweak Region 1 tracking system is one of three tracking systems designed to measure the <math>Q^2</math> profile of elastically scattered electrons as well as the background contributions to the parity violating signal.  The Region 1 tracking system is located behind the first collimator at a distance of about 550 cm from the main torus magnet ( 200 cm from the target) as show in the left hand of Figure 1.  The collimator divides the <math>\phi</math> acceptance into 8 regions (octants) and reduces the azimuthal acceptance by almost 30 percent.  The right hand figure below shows the elastic scattering profile overlayed on top of one of the octants.  The Region 1 tracking system will measure the electron scattering angle at only 2 of the octants at a time and will rotate in <math>\phi</math>  to perform measurements in the remaining octants.

[[Image:QweakApparatusNearR1_FinalVersion.png | 300 px]]
[[Image:QweakqstCollimatorGeometry_RateOverlay.jpg | 300 px]]
:Figure 1.  Left: The Qweak apparatus near the Region 1 tracking system.  Right: A view of the electron profile overlayed on top of the fnal collimator design. 

The high radiation flux and the small detector footprint were two of the biggest challenges facing the Region 1 tracking system.  An ionization chamber equipped with Gas Electron Multipliers (GEM) was chosen over a standard wire chamber design in order to accommodate the high radiation flux near the target.  The GEM preamplifiers allow smaller ionization cell sizes thereby resulting in ionization chamber rise times of 50 nanoseconds or less.  The ionization chamber itself is constructed from Ertalyte, a machinable plastic material which can withstand the high radiation environment.  The material's strength allows the chamber to have thin walls which prevent the chamber from extending into adjacent octants.  
The three major components to the Qweak Region 1 detector, the GEM preamplifiers, the charge collector, and the ionization chamber are described below.
====Preamplifier design and procurement====

Figure 2 below shows the custom designed GEM preamplifier for the Qweak Region 1 tracking system.  The preamplifier is a 50 micron thick kapton foil clad on both sides with 5 microns of copper.  Holes are etched into the foil such that a high voltage (HV) applied across the top and bottom copper plates will create an electric field strong enough to cause charge to pass through the hole and multiply much like the avalanche region of a drift chamber.    Engineers from the Idaho Accelerator Center (IAC) designed the shape of the foils and the location of 6 tabs used for HV connections, as shown in the left hand figure below.  This generic design allows one to use the part for any GEM amplification stage simply by cutting off the unused HV tabs.  The actual preamp is shown on the right hand side of the figure below.   Although this is a simple part, it is a clear example of how the infrastructure at the IAC can be leveraged in support of our physics mission.

[[Image:Qweak_GEM_preamp.jpg | 300 px]][[File:GEM_Foils_mounted_on_the_frame_1.jpg|250px]]
:Figure 2: The GEM preamplifier design and a picture of the manufactured part.

==== Charge Collector Design ====

The charge collector for Qweak's region 1 tracking system is shown in Figure 3.  One layer of the copper charge contains a series of concentric strips aligned with the electron scattering angle <math>\theta</math>.  Each of the red strips shown on the left side in Figure 3 is 400 microns wide and will measure the elastic electron scattering angle to within 0.1 mrad.  The blue lines, shown in the middle figure, are representative of the <math>\phi</math> scattering angle.  A large number of graduate student hours were needed to place each strip into the correct position using PC board design software.  Software compatibility issues with the vendor were also a major time sink of several months before the part could be accurately manufactured according to our specifications.  This single part represents 6 months of graduate students and is one example of a practical component to a student's educational experience.   The photo in Figure 3 shows the final charge collector delivered on 11/12/08.
  
[[Image:BOTTOM_copper.jpg | 350px]][[Image:TOP_copper.jpg | 350px]][[Image:CERN_Qweak_Charge_Collector_2.jpg | 350px]]
<br>
:Figure 3.  Individual layers of the charge collector design and a photo of the manufactured device.

==== Ionization Chamber Construction====

The ionization chamber for the Qweak Region 1 tracking system is placed less than a quarter meter after the target and has a small profile.  A collimator in front of this detector divides the electron scattering angular range into octants reducing the angular acceptance range by about 30 percent.   The goal was to construct a chamber which moves between octants and does not interfere with adjacent octants.  The left picture in Figure 4 shows the top half of the ionization chamber placed on top of a full scale representation of electrons exiting the first collimator in front of Region 1.  Both graduate students, Julian Salamanca and Tamar Didbaridze, contributed to the construction of the Qweak chambers.  As seen in Figure 4, the electron profile is enclosed by the detector acceptance and the ionization chamber frame is in the shadow of the collimator.  The completed chambers are shown on the right hand side of Figure 4. A HV distribution board was designed by physics undergraduate student Jordan Keough and is visible along with BNC connectors near the top of the detectors.

[[Image:QweakR1_TopWindowOverlayedOntoElectronProfile_1.jpg | 400px]][[File:QweakR1_Detectors_Overlayed_E-profile.png | 450 px]]

:Figure 4.  Left: A full scale picture of the electron profile and the top half of the ionization chamber. Right: Completed Region1 tracking system.  The which paper on top of the entrance window represents elastic electrons which enter the Cherenkov detectors used to measure the parity violating asymmetry.

=== Qweak readout electronics ===

The front end readout electronics for Qweak's region 1 tracking system will need to withstand the high radiation environment as well as have a fast throughput.   One detector readout option being pursed is the VFAT digitization board developed at CERN for the TOTEM experiment.  It was designed to be used for either silicon or GEM based detectors.  The board can sample it's 128 input channels at 40 MHz and store up to 128 triggered events.  The VFAT board has been designed to withstand up to 100 Mrad of radiation which is more than sufficient for Qweak.  The VFAT card digitizes the analog output of the GEM detector to indicate the presence of a hit on one of the charge collector's copper strips.   The PI has been using his start up funds to develop the infrastructure needed to deploy this front end electronics for the Qweak's region 1 tracking system.  This infrastructure is described below.


The front end electronics to readout a detector contains three basic elements.  The VFAT readout board will convert the analog charge observed on a charge collector strip to a digital signal which identifies the presence of a hit on the strip.  A Gumstick controller is a small unix computer used to program the VFAT card and set parameters like the amplifier gain, the threshold, and check for failed flip/flops.  A VME I/O board will receive the LVDS digital signals from the VFAT board and store them for readout by a single board computer located in the VME crate.   For the past year, Brian Oborn has been working on the Gumstick controller to communicate with a VFAT board.  Undergraduate student, Jordan Keough, is spending the summer designing a signal switchyard to establish lines of communication between the Gumstick computer, the VFAT board, and the VME I/O module.


==== VFAT board communication====

The figure below illustrates the progress which has taken place developing the VFAT readout infrastructure.  The first image illustrates a test setup showing the VFAT chip output viewed by an oscilloscope during our signal tests.  The second image is a scope picture iidentifying the LVDS communication protocols when we program the chip.  The last image shows a web interface we are using to program the chip.  The Gumstick computer has a webserver loaded which will allow a web browser to set VFAT parameters remotely from the counting house at JLAB.  

[[Image:VFATApparatus_FirstSignals.jpg | 200 px]][[Image:i2c_scope_write_42.xfig.png | 200 px]][[Image:VFAT_WebinterfaceScreenshot.jpg | 200 px]][[Image:VFAT_Bottom_HiRes.png|200px]]

==== Readout switchyard====

The lines of communication between the VFAT readout board, the Gumstick controller, and the VME FPGA I/O module are managed by a signal switchyard being designed at ISU.  Brian Oborn, a technician from the IAC, is mentoring Jordan Keough's design of the signal switchyard board.  Jordan is a physics undergraduate.  The switchyard will divert signals between the three detector readout elements to their appropriate destination.  I2C signals will travel between the Gum stick control computer to the VFAT readout card according to address switches on the switchyard board.  The switchyard board will also be used to input clock signals for sampling the detector as well as a Flip Flop scan signal to check for radiation damage to the board.  The switchyard will send LVDS signals containing the Detector data from the VFAT readout board to the VME FPGA I/O module.

[[Image:BreakOutBox.jpg | 400 px]]
[[Image:VFAT_Breakout_REV3_Design_Schematic.png | 400 px]]
[[Image:VFAT_Breakout_REV3.png | 400 px]]


[[File:GEM_DAQ_Gumstix_LDS_Setup_2009.png | 400 px]]

=== Physics Analysis===


While the construction and testing of ionization chambers for Qweak is a valuable graduate student hardware experience, the graduate student supported by this grant will need to write a thesis on a research physics topic.  Due to the time constraints involved, Tamar Didberidze, has been doing her physics research on data that has already been taken.  She has decided to work  towards measuring the ratio of polarized to unpolarized down quark distribution in the nucleon.  The PI's previous work at JLAB involved collecting polarized electron scattering data from polarized ammonia targets using the CLAS.  Tamar will be able to analyze the polarized structure function data already taken and not wait for  data from the Qweak experiment in order to graduate from with a Ph. D. in a timescale consistent with such a degree.  Preliminary results from her analysis are shown in the next section.

==What are your major findings from the activities identified above==

In addition to completing the construction of the Region 1 tracking chambers for Qweak, the support from this proposal resulted in several findings.  The first finding was a proof in principle of a candidate readout system for the Qweak experiment.  A measurement of the pion center of mass phi angle distribution is the second finding to report.  The third finding was a serendipitous result involving experimentation with a drift chamber proto-type system for JLab’s Hall B.
===Qweak readout  Speed tests====
The VFAT is a candidate front end readout card for Qweak's region 1 tracking system.  The VFAT chip has been designed to sample the detector analog output at 40 MHz.   Although elastically scattered electrons which traverse the entire Qweak apparatus are expected to trigger the readout system at rates of about 1 kHz, there is a large background due to moller scattering resulting in electron rates of 12 MHz/nA uniformly distributed over the entire region 1 acceptance.   The moller rate on a single detector strip would be about 25 kHz/nA.  This restricts the region 1 tracking system to operating currents below 400 nA since the detector rise time of 50 nanoseconds will result in signal pileup if the ionization particle flux rates exceed 10 MHz.  The VFAT board sampling at 40 MHz would, by itself, satisfy the readout requirements of Qweak.  

The remaining question is whether the VFAT digital output can be transferred to the data acquisition system without introducing a bottleneck.  The CERN engineer who designed the VFAT board suggested the use of a Field Programmable Gate Array (FPGA).   Based on that recommendations, we decided to test a VME 1495 FPGA I/O module from CAEN.  We observed read and write speeds between the VME backplane and the FPGA user registers of 16 bits to USER FPGA in 330 ns.  This measurement corresponds to a throughput speed of 6 MB/sec compared to a requirement of 0.5 KB/sec for Qweak.  

===Comparison with other experiments===

In addition to working on Qweak hardware, the graduate student on this grant, Tamar Didberidze, is also analyzing data from a previous experiment for the physics part of her thesis.  The data under analysis was taken in JLab’s Hall B as part of the polarized structure function program.  Tamar is interested in using that data set to extract the ratio of the polarized down quark distribution to the unpolarized (Δd/d).  Semi exclusive pion production will be used to extract this ratio.  As a first step, Tamar has looked at single pion production in the exclusive channel  H(e,e’π)n, where the neutron is detected using missing mass techniques.  Figure 1 below shows the observed counting rate as a function of the pion phi angle in the center of mass frame.  The data is compared with the unpolarized experiment E99-107, also done using the CLAS, by ignoring the beam and target polarization information in the EG1 experiment.  


Cuts: EC_inner>0.06, EC_tot/p>0.2, nphe>2.5, <math>0.9<M_x<1.1</math>, <math>1.1<W<1.5</math> and <math>0.6<cos\theta_{pion}^{CM}<0.8</math>.<br>
[[Image:phi_angle_cm_frame_vs_rate_two_results_compared_cos_theta_0-6_0-8.jpg|500px]]<br>

:Figure 1:  A comparison of the center of mass pion phi angle distribution between the polarized EG1 experiment and the unpolarized E99-107 experiment.  The kinematic region was constrained to 0.6 < cos(θCMπ) < 0.8, 1.1 < W < 1.5 GeV, and 0.9 < MX < 1.1 GeV.  θCMπ is the pion scattering angle in the CM frame

===Drift Chamber Feedthroughs===

As part of her graduate studies, Tamar Didberidze has been quantifying the performance of two proto-type drift chambers for JLab’s Hall B. The ionization chamber principle is similar to the GEM chambers being built for Qweak and provided a good training experience for her before beginning constructing the Qweak chambers.   Two ionization chamber proto-types were built by JLab and sent to ISU. They are identical except that one uses an all plastic feedthrough to hold the drift chamber wires and another has a plastic feedthrough with a metal tip where the wire makes contact with the feedthrough. The proto-type detectors will be used to evaluate the efficiency of the chamber as a function of the ionizing particles position from the end of the wire. A Garfield simulation leads one to believe that the plastic tipped feedthrough will result in a less efficient detector near the end of the wire due to less radial electric field lines. The answer to this question will impact the design of drift chambers for the CLAS 12 upgrade.  
During this funding cycle, Tamar discovered, as shown in on the left in Figure 2, that the proto-type detector using plastic feedthroughs is noisier, requiring a higher discriminator threshold,  than the one with metal tips.  The right graph in Figure 2 shows our progress in evaluating the chamber efficiency as a function of the location of the ionization event from the end of the wire (endplate).  The data was taken using one of the accelerators at the IAC.  We did not have sufficient beam time to produce definitive results and we would like to improve our apparatus before attempting another measurement. 


[[Image:discriminator_threshold_vs_rate_using_VPI_Post_Amp_for_Metalica_and_Plastika_HV_1450V_1500V_1.jpg|400px]]
[[Image:HRRL_16-04-09_Position_vs_Rate_ADCMeasuremts_AllData_UsingSimpleErrorCalculation.jpg|400px]]

:Figure 2: Drift Chamber cosmic ray detection rate as a function of discriminator voltage is shown in the left figure above.  Metalica has metal tipped feedthroughs while Plastica does not.  The right figure shows the decrease in efficiency as the point of ionization approaches the end of the wire.  An Aluminum brick was used to block the 3 MeV electrons in order to measure the unlocalized photon background.  At least half of the measured ionization events were the result of  the photon background.

==What research and teaching skills and experience has the project helped provide to those who worked on the project==

Describe the opportunities for training and development provided by your project.

As part of their graduate studies, Tamar Didberidze and  Julian Slamanca,  gained skills and experiences in the area of detector development.  The design of a charge collector for the Qweak detector exposed them to modern circuit design software as well as some of the compatibility issues between software packages.  The construction of ionization chambers using modern machinable plastics like Ertalyte exposed students to conventional machine shop practices and the use of a milling machine.  The evaluation of prototype detectors gives students signal processing experience using both analog and digital devices.  Both single cosmic events as well as coincidence events using multiple detectors such as scintillators and drift chambers is an on going experiment in our Laboratory for Detector Science.  Students are exposed to and gain experience with NIM and VME based signal processing systems.  Graduate students also gain teaching experience mentoring the undergraduates that have taken part in the projects described in the Activities section of this report.

==What outreach activities have you undertaken to increase public understanding of, and participation in, science and technology?==
Describe outreach activities your project has undertaken.

The physics department at ISU travels to local schools to perform physics demonstrations in an effort to increase the public's understanding of science and technology.  The demonstrations occur at night in order to illustrate physics principles to students and their parents.  I went to Syringa elementary school during this last funding cycle to demonstrate several principles of electricity to student and their parents.  A small Van de Graf was used to demonstrate principles of conduction.  The principles of producting electricity were demonstrated using solenoids and the effect of liquid nitrogen on Eddy currents induced in a copper conducter were some of the popular components of the demonstrations.

The physics department also holds a mentoring program for high school teachers and their students during the first month of summer.  I instructed a group of about 20 teachers and student on the operating principles of drift chambers, scintillators, and solid state detectors.  He-3 neutron detectors will be given to the science teachers for use at their home institution.  As a result, the neutron detection principle of a He-3 detector was the main focus of the lecture.  The He-3 detectors  are from a completed experiment at PNNL laboratories and were made available to ISU due to its research partnership with PNNL Laboratories.  The arrangement is a fortuitous example of how research and education can combine efforts and  improve the public's understanding of science and technology.

=Publications and Products=

In this section, you will be asked to describe the tangible products coming out of your project. Specifically:

What have you published as a result of this work?
Journal publications 

Books or other non-periodical, one-time publications 

What Web site or other Internet site have you created?

What other specific products (databases, physical collections, educational aids, software, instruments, or the like) have you developed? 

==What have you published as a result of this work?==

This work is in progress and has not resulted in any publications.

==Journal publications ==
#Deeply Virtual Compton Scattering Beam-Spin Asymmetries., F.X. Girod et al. (The CLAS Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 162002 (2008). http://link.aps.org/abstract/PRL/v100/e162002 
#Beam spin asymmetry in deep and exclusive p0 electroproduction., R. De Masi et al. (The CLAS Collaboration), Phys. Rev. C 77, 042201 (2008). http://link.aps.org/abstract/PRC/v77/e042201 
#Cross Sections for gamma p to K0*+ Sigma at Egamma=1.7-3.0 GeV , I. Hleiqawi, et. al., Phys. Rev. C 75,2007, 042201. 
#Separated Structure Functions for the Exclusive electroproduction of K+ Lambda and K+ Sigma Final States , P. Ambrozewicz, et. al., Phys. Rev. C 75,2007, 045203. 
#First measurement of Beam Recoil Observables C(x) and C(z) in hyperon Photoproduction , R. Bradford, et. al., Phys. Rev. C 75,2007, 035205. 
Quark-Hadron Duality in Spin Structure Functions g1p and g1d , P. Bosted, et. al., Phys. Rev. C 75,2007, 035203.

==Books or other non-periodical, one-time publications ==
"An Accelerator Based Cargo Container Inspection System for Nuclear Materials", T. A. Forest, et. al., Eight International Topical Meeting on Nuclear Applications and Utilization of Accelerators,  American Nuclear Society,  pg 470, Aug. 2007

==What Web site or other Internet site have you created?==

=== Wiki===

==What other specific products (databases, physical collections, educational aids, software, instruments, or the like) have you developed? ==
=Contributions=
Now we invite you to explain ways in which your work, your findings, and specific products of your project are significant. Describe the unique contributions, major accomplishments, innovations and successes of your project relative to :

the principal discipline(s) of the project; 

other disciplines of science or engineering; 

the development of human resources; 

the physical, institutional, or information resources that form the infrastructure for research and education; and 

other aspects of public welfare beyond science and engineering, such as commercial technology, the economy, cost-efficient environmental protection, or solutions to social problems. 

==How have your findings, techniques you developed or extended, or other products from your project contributed to the principal disciplinary field(s) of the project?==
=Special Requirements=

[http://wiki.iac.isu.edu/index.php/2007_Proposal Go Back] [[2007_Proposal]]